Skip to main content
← Back to BlogComparisonFebruary 2025

ConsumerShield vs Avvo: Specialized vs General Legal Help

Avvo is one of the biggest legal directories online. They have ratings, reviews, and a Q&A section. But is that what you need when a debt collector is breaking the law?

What Avvo Actually Is

Avvo is three things:

  1. A lawyer directory - search by practice area and location
  2. A rating system - attorneys rated 1-10 based on experience, reviews, etc.
  3. A Q&A forum - ask legal questions, get answers from attorneys

It's useful for finding any type of lawyer. But there's a catch.

The Avvo Ratings Problem

Avvo ratings aren't based on case outcomes. They're based on:

  • Years of experience
  • Professional achievements
  • Client reviews (easy to game)
  • Profile completeness

A 10-rated attorney might be great. Or they might just have a well-optimized profile. You don't know until you hire them.

The ConsumerShield Difference

FeatureConsumerShieldAvvo
TypeCase matching serviceDirectory/search engine
You do the work?No - we match youYes - you search/call attorneys
Attorney vettingTrack record in consumer casesRating algorithm
Case evaluationFree violation checkerNone (just directory)
Cost structureGuaranteed fee-shiftingVaries by attorney

The Consumer Law Blind Spot

Here's Avvo's biggest problem for debt collection cases: most general attorneys don't understand fee-shifting.

If you search "debt collection attorney" on Avvo, you might find someone who handles it occasionally. They might want a retainer. They might charge hourly.

That's insane. Under the FDCPA, the debt collector pays your attorney fees when you win. Any attorney charging YOU upfront doesn't specialize in this area.

ConsumerShield attorneys take cases on contingency because they know they'll get paid by the collector. That's how specialized they are.

When to Use Avvo

  • You need a lawyer for something other than consumer protection
  • You want to read reviews before hiring
  • You have time to call multiple attorneys yourself

When to Use ConsumerShield

  • A debt collector is harassing you
  • You're getting robocalls or spam texts
  • Your credit report has errors
  • You want someone who does this all day, every day
  • You don't want to pay a dime upfront

The Bottom Line

Avvo is Google for lawyers. ConsumerShield is a specialist referral service.

If you have a consumer protection case, why would you search a general directory when you can go directly to attorneys who have sued your exact debt collector before?

Think You Have a Case?

Our free violation checker identifies FDCPA, TCPA, and FCRA violations in under 2 minutes.

Check Your Rights Free